The underclassmen group represents a collection of players who have already established a significant presence within Indiana high school volleyball. This year’s selections were evaluated on their overall impact, consistency against top competition, and ability to influence match outcomes in meaningful ways. Many of these athletes stepped into major roles earlier than expected, providing production and reliability typically seen from upperclassmen. Their performances reflect a strong foundation of technical skill and competitive maturity.
As programs across the state continue to elevate their level of play, this underclassmen class signals a promising future for Indiana volleyball. Several honorees have already become focal points within their systems, while others have emerged as key contributors in postseason environments. The depth of this group underscores the continued development within the sport and positions Indiana for another cycle of strong college-level talent in the coming years.
| UNDERCLASSMEN | |
| Chloe Ritchie | Yorktown |
| Makenzie Griffiths | New Prairie |
| Caroline Ward | Tri West |
| Casyn Comer | Westfield |
| Avery Walter | Avon |
| Ella Stone | Roncalli |
| Anabelle Schembra | Center Grove |
| Caroline Hanchar | Cathedral |
| Shania Rhamy | Southwood |
| Cala Haffner | FW Carroll |
| Avery Bastien | Center Grove |
| Emery Cardinal | Guerin Catholic |
| Lila Bruszewski | Carmel |
| Luca Bombacnino | Chestergon |
| Audrey Utterback | Plainfield |
| AT LARGE | |
| Paige Furbee | Castle |
| Macy Sorg | Floyd Central |
| Kendyl Strack | Westfield |
| Kendall Rowray | Yorktown |
| Nora Breitwieser | Jasper |