Volleyball | State champions, record-setting performers and some of Indiana’s most accomplished seniors headline the IHSVCA’s five finalists.
The Indiana High School Volleyball Coaches Association (IHSVCA) announced its five finalists for the 2026 Indiana Miss Volleyball award Monday evening, recognizing five seniors whose careers have helped shape the state’s volleyball landscape. Westfield’s Carsyn Comer, Southwood’s Shania Rhamy, Center Grove’s Anabelle Schembra, Fort Wayne Carroll’s Sarah Stegall and Tri-West’s Caroline Ward make up this year’s group. Together they have combined for multiple state championships, school records and individual milestones, and each brings a different résumé into consideration.
The award recognizes more than statistical production. The IHSVCA evaluates career accomplishments, academic achievement, community involvement and character through a two-committee selection process. The winner will be announced Sunday, Nov. 22, during the IHSVCA All-Star Matches at Lawrence North High School in Indianapolis.
Carsyn Comer, Westfield
Middle hitter | Louisville commit | 28-3 | Class 4A semi-state finalist
Comer closed her senior season with 269 kills, a .509 hitting percentage, 44 aces, 77 blocks and 41 digs. The 6-foot-3 middle hitter passed 1,000 career kills during Westfield’s semi-state match against Carroll and finished with 1,001 kills, 313 blocks and 123 aces across four varsity seasons. Her .471 career hitting percentage reflects remarkable efficiency at the net. Comer helped lead Westfield to consecutive regional championships, ending a drought that dated to 2011.
Shania Rhamy, Southwood
Outside hitter | Kentucky commit | 32-3 | Class 2A semi-state finalist
Rhamy delivered 401 kills on .389 hitting, along with 310 digs, 35 aces, 37 blocks and 42 assists, in her final season. She recorded double-digit kills in 24 matches, including a season-high 22 against Manchester. Her career totals include 1,558 kills, 1,246 digs and 222 aces. Rhamy helped Southwood produce four straight 30-win seasons and four straight regional championships, highlighted by the Knights’ Class 1A state title in 2023.
Anabelle Schembra, Center Grove
Setter | UCF commit | 34-5 | Class 4A state runner-up
Schembra posted career highs in every major statistical category, finishing with 1,185 assists, 326 digs, 107 kills, 81 aces and 54 blocks. She broke Center Grove’s all-time assists record during the sectional semifinals and finished her four-year career with 4,210 assists, including three straight seasons of more than 1,000. Her 50-assist performance against Yorktown helped send Center Grove to its first state championship appearance since 2000. Schembra finished her career with four sectional championships and two regional titles.
Sarah Stegall, Fort Wayne Carroll
Outside hitter | Notre Dame commit | 36-1 | Class 4A state champion
Stegall helped Carroll win its third straight Class 4A state championship with a career-best 481 kills on .354 hitting. She added 71 aces, 46 blocks and 197 digs, with 52 kills coming across the final two weekends of the postseason. Despite missing her sophomore season with an injury, Stegall finished with 988 career kills, 317 digs, 101 aces and 97 blocks. She graduates as a three-time state champion and one of the central pieces of Carroll’s championship run.
Caroline Ward, Tri-West
Outside hitter | SMU commit | 31-6 | Class 3A state champion
Ward put together one of the state’s most productive offensive seasons, recording 735 kills on .372 hitting with 312 digs, 60 aces, 39 blocks and 22 assists. She delivered 26 kills in Tri-West’s state championship win over West Noble, helping secure the first volleyball state title in school history. Ward finished her career with 1,969 kills despite an injury-shortened sophomore season. She also helped guide the Bruins to four straight semi-state appearances, one of the most successful stretches in program history.
Ready to Take Your Recruitment to the Next Level?
Get verified. Gain exposure. Connect with college programs. The Indiana Showcase gives athletes an opportunity to compete, showcase their abilities, and take control of their recruiting journey.













Leave a Reply