There are several candidates worthy to be considered frontrunners for the Indiana Preps Player of the Year. This is awarded to the top Senior football player.
Ben Davis quarterback Kyle Castner was the 2014 Indiana Preps Player of the Year.

(not in any order)

Brandon Peters, Quarterback – Avon

Chris Evans, Running Back/Wide Receiver – Ben Davis

Austin Mack, Wide Receiver – FW Luers

Kiante Enis, Running Back – Winchester

Luke Johnston, Quarterback – Southport

Alex Neligh, Quarterback – New Palestine