| SMALL SCHOOL | CLASS A-3A | |
| QB | Nolan Buckman | Brebeuf Jesuit |
| RB | Robert Lamar | Clarksville |
| RB | Kyle Turanchick | Oak Hill |
| TE | Sam West | Greensburg |
| WR | Gannan Howes | Hanover Central |
| WR | Luke Jones | Monroe Central |
| OL | Ryan Hildeman | Hanover Central |
| OL | Cameron Craig | Concordia |
| OL | Justin Schroeder | Frontier |
| OL | Luke Amann | West Lafayette |
| OL | Colten Cahill | North Harrison |
| APB | Derron Hazzard | Riverton Parke |
| DL | Brody Bolyn | Norwell |
| DL | Kam Patterson | Indy Lutheran |
| DL | Jordan Cree | Rensselear Central |
| DL | Tamir Woods | Indy Scecina |
| LB | John Nabors | Covenant Christian |
| LB | Drayk Bowen | Andrean |
| LB | Noah Richhart | Laville |
| DB | Nick Thompson | FW Luers |
| DB | Gannen Howes | Hanover Central |
| DB | Reid Messer | North Decatur |
| DB | Kolton Nanko | Yorktown |
| ATH | DeeJay McFerson | Speedway |
| K/P | Josiah Smith | Western Boone |
Indiana Preps 2022 Preseason All State Top 22 – Small School
