Recognizing the Best in a Historic Season for Girls Flag Football in Indiana
The 2025 fall season marked a milestone for girls flag football in the Hoosier State — and for Indiana Preps. Our inaugural season covering the sport delivered everything we hoped for: elite athletes, fast-paced play, inspiring storylines, and a championship atmosphere that set a new standard.
It all culminated under the lights at Grand Park, where Penn High School completed a perfect 13–0 season and claimed the first IHSAA Girls Flag Football State Championship in history with a 35–12 victory over Lawrence North. A defining moment for the sport — and a thrilling conclusion to Year One for our coverage team.
Today, we proudly unveil the 2025 Indiana Preps Girls Flag Football All-State Teams, beginning with our Senior Top 22. Order Your All State Patch Here
2025 Indiana Preps Girls Flag Football All-State Senior Top 22 Team
Here is your complete list of the top senior performers in the state, representing elite playmakers, leaders, and program-changers from across Indiana:
| All Senior Team | ||||
| Offense | Defense | |||
| Arynn Garrard | Cathedral | Igboamaka Odeluga | Munster | |
| Addison Collins | Evansville Mater Dei | Laniya Gaines | Lawrence North | |
| Jaslynn Sanchez | Munster High School | Macy Little | Penn | |
| Lauren Petras | Penn | Tnai Cohen | Pike | |
| Abrielle Alexander | Lawrence North | Amira Puckett | Pike | |
| Breanna Hampton | North Central | |||
| Da’Niyah Johnson | Lafayette Jefferson | Cydnei Harper | Lawrence North | |
| Josie Friend | Evansville Mater Dei | Paris Page | Lawrence North | |
| Ka’Nyriah Ridley | Lawrence North | Kloe Klein | Penn | |
| Kami Bauer | Penn | Ky Williams | Castle | |
| Cassidy Daniels | North Central | |||
| McKenna Lawson | Terre Haute North | Mary Maher | South Bend St. Joseph | |
| Mary Stack | South Bend St. Joseph | |||
| Brennah Cerny | Roncalli |
Player of the Year Honors
Offensive Player of the Year: Arynn Garrard — Cathedral (Senior)
One of the most dynamic athletes in the state, Garrard delivered fireworks every opportunity. With nearly 20 total touchdowns, she was a nightmare matchup and a true engine of Cathedral’s offense. Her playmaking ability has drawn significant collegiate interest — 10+ college opportunities and counting.
Defensive Player of the Year: Macy Little — Penn (Senior)
The heartbeat of Penn’s undefeated championship defense, Little was relentless. Her instincts and ball-hawking skills tilted games in Penn’s favor all season long. She finished the season with a staggering 17 interceptions, anchoring a unit that smothered opponents from Week 1 through the state finals.
Underclassmen All-State Team — Coming Next
Our Underclassmen Top 22 — featuring the rising stars and future faces of Indiana girls flag football — will be announced shortly.
A Season Worth Celebrating
From high-scoring battles to breakthrough programs to the growing wave of college opportunities, the 2025 season showcased just how bright the future of girls flag football is in Indiana. We’re honored to spotlight these athletes, their accomplishments, and their impact on a historic year.
Stay tuned for our upcoming All-State releases in:
- Girls Volleyball
- Boys Tackle Football
The best is still ahead.
This is outstanding! Thank you for the support of girls flag football! These young ladies put in the time, sweat, and tears to be chosen. Congratulations to all of you!